By: Lee Anne Siegmund
“Muscle confusion” is one of those terms that the fitness industry throws around. It’s like “feel the burn” or “no pain no gain”. I guess they are trying to convince us that muscles can only get stronger if they hurt and are terribly confused. It doesn’t sound pleasant and what’s more, it doesn’t make any sense.
Muscles cannot be confused first of all. They only do what they are told and have no clue why. Here’s how skeletal muscles work. First, a force of some sort is imposed on the body. This could be the weight of your body along with gravity. It could be a resistance band, a dumbbell or even the wind. Something pushes or pulls on your body or a part of your body and your nervous system responds.
Your brain and spinal cord are capable of receiving the message that there is a “force” and then responding by sending electrical signals to the muscle. These signals travel down the nerve (motor neuron) to a place on the muscle fibers called the motor unit. This is where these electrical signals become messages that tell the fiber to contract, or shorten. Likewise, the muscle will re-lengthen on command. As a matter of fact, muscles on the opposite side of the limb will be temporarily inhibited in order to allow the limb to move.
Does this sound like confusion? Our nervous system and muscles are amazing! The way they respond quickly and accurately to forces imposed on them is nothing short of miraculous. The nervous system commands just enough muscle fibers and the right kind of fibers to contract to get the job done.
Even more amazing is that our muscles will adapt based on the type of training we do. We call this “imposed demand.” The muscles will adapt appropriately and specifically to the imposed demand. If we lift a 2# weight over and over, we may improve endurance, but won’t affect strength all that much. But when the weight is heavy enough that we can only lift it 8 times or so, we will likely be improving or maintaining our strength.
This “specific adaptation to imposed demand” is the result of planned progression. The muscles are not confused at all. On the contrary, the nervous system and motor unit together have created a very carefully planned orchestration of signals and contractions in order to overcome the force and as a result will strengthen the muscle.
There is no confusion involved in safe, planned progression of exercise. Simply because muscles “get used to” a certain resistance or exercise does not mean we have to mix up our exercise routine haphazardly. Randomly changing how we exercise, the weight we use or how we do it, predisposes to injury. If you want to progress, don’t attempt to “confuse” your muscles. Instead, carefully train your nervous system by strategically making gradual changes in quantity, direction and speed of the force. That will give you results and more importantly, it will be safer. No confusion about that.
To find a professional who will help you develop a strength training plan that will progress you safely and gradually, go to: http://www.resistancetrainingspecialist.com/roster.html